Varta
← Back to stories

From The Pioneer

Center-Right Owned by The Pioneer

Bengal BJP MLA claims firecracker smoke can cure diseases, sparks controversy

Bengal BJP MLA claims firecracker smoke can cure diseases, sparks controversy

What's behind this

BJP MLA Papiya Adhikari of Tollygunge said firecrackers can cure several diseases, citing an old ancestral saying. The remark drew backlash, and on Monday, November 9 she told ANI she was retracting the statement. The controversy comes as the Central Pollution Control Board data show Kolkata’s average Air Quality Index at 301, classifying the city’s air as ‘very poor’.

AI-generated overview from 2 outlets. It summarises their reporting and adds no reporting of its own.

What each side is saying

One outlet's own words from each side of the spectrum. Quoted, not summarised.

  • left · 1 outlet

    Kolkata: Facing backlash for crediting firecrackers with curing some diseases, BJP’s MLA from Tollygunge in West Bengal, Papia Adhikary, on Monday, November 9, sought to take her statement back. Speaking to ANI, she said, “There is an old saying from our ancestors regarding these traditions. In…

    — The Siasat Daily

  • center · 1 outlet

    According to data from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), Kolkata's average Air Quality Index (AQI) stood at 301, placing it in the 'very poor' category.

    — Deccan Chronicle

  • right · 1 outlet

    KOLKATA: Bharatiya Janata Party MLA Papia Adhikari has triggered a controversy by claiming that bursting firecrackers can cure diseases during a Kali Puja event in her Tollygunge constituency in Kolkata. The legislator remarked while inaugurating a Kali Puja idol at a community pandal on Saturday…

    — The Pioneer

RSS excerpt

KOLKATA: Bharatiya Janata Party MLA Papia Adhikari has triggered a controversy by claiming that bursting firecrackers can cure diseases during a Kali Puja event in her Tollygunge constituency in Kolkata. The legislator remarked while inaugurating a Kali Puja idol at a community pandal on Saturday…

Coverage arrived over 3 hours — first from The Pioneer, latest from Deccan Chronicle.

✓ Corroborated Coverage ⚡ Cross-Spectrum Consensus 3 news outlets reporting

Fact-Check & Bias Analysis

Verified by independent outlets with different editorial leanings.

Coverage Bias Distribution

Based on 3 reporting publishers
Left / Center-Left 1 (33%)
Center 1 (33%)
Center-Right / Right 1 (34%)

Compare all reporting outlets (3)

  1. The Pioneer Center-Right The Pioneer Current article

    Bengal BJP MLA claims firecracker smoke can cure diseases, sparks controversy

    KOLKATA: Bharatiya Janata Party MLA Papia Adhikari has triggered a controversy by claiming that bursting firecrackers can cure diseases during a Kali Puja event in her Tollygunge constituency in Kolkata. The legislator remarked while inaugurating a Kali Puja idol at a community pandal on Saturday…

  2. 3 hours later
  3. 28 minutes later

Read more news

See all latest stories →