Varta
← Back to stories

From The Hindu

Owned by Kasturi & Sons Ltd.

Justice Karnan’s incident brought judicial misconduct to the forefront

Justice Karnan’s incident brought judicial misconduct to the forefront

What's behind this

Justice C.S. Karnan’s death in Chennai, reported as occurring on a Friday at age 71, has revived debate over judicial misconduct. His career, marked by confrontations with the higher judiciary, allegations of corruption against twenty judges, a claim of caste bias, and becoming the first serving judge imprisoned for contempt, prompted calls to revisit the selection and appointment process for constitutional courts and to consider an alternative removal mechanism. The incident therefore placed the need for reforms in judge selection and accountability at the forefront of public discussion.

AI-generated overview from 6 outlets. It summarises their reporting and adds no reporting of its own.

RSS excerpt

Two problems were raised in the aftermath — The need to revisit the process of selection/appointment of judges to constitutional courts, the need for an alternative to removal process to tackle judicial misconduct.

Coverage arrived over 2 hours. First from Hindustan Times, latest from The Hindu.

High Corroboration 8 news outlets reporting

How this event was covered

First reported by Hindustan Times at 10:49 UTC on 13 Nov.

Everything here arrived on one day, and nothing since.

Across 1 desk: india.

All 8 newsrooms, and who owns them

Compare all reporting outlets (8)

  1. 44 minutes later
  2. 1 hour later
  3. 5 minutes later
  4. 14 minutes later
  5. 9 minutes later
  6. 17 minutes later
  7. 3 minutes later
  8. The Hindu Kasturi & Sons Ltd. Current article

    Justice Karnan’s incident brought judicial misconduct to the forefront

    Two problems were raised in the aftermath — The need to revisit the process of selection/appointment of judges to constitutional courts, the need for an alternative to removal process to tackle judicial misconduct.

Who did not run this

8 newsrooms ran this event. 21 others published in India recently and did not.

See which 21 newsrooms
  • ANI ANI Media
  • Deccan Chronicle Deccan Chronicle Holdings
  • Free Press Kashmir Free Press Kashmir
  • Frontline The Hindu Group (Kasturi & Sons)
  • Greater Kashmir GK Communications Pvt. Ltd.
  • India Today Living Media India
  • Kashmir Life Kashmir Life
  • Kashmir Observer Kashmir Observer
  • Mathrubhumi English Mathrubhumi Printing & Publishing Co.
  • NE Now NE Now
  • Organiser Bharatiya Prakashan (RSS)
  • Orissa Post Eastern Media Ltd (Sambad Group)
  • Rising Kashmir Rising Kashmir
  • The Avenue Mail The Avenue Mail
  • The Economic Times Bennett, Coleman & Co.
  • The Hans India
  • The Logical Indian The Logical Indian (independent digital media)
  • The Morung Express
  • The New Indian Express Express Publications (Madurai) Ltd.
  • The Times of India Bennett, Coleman & Co.
  • The Tribune The Tribune Trust

Counted from the newest hundred stories in the section, not from every newsroom in India.

Read more news

See all latest stories →